How can this be fair?
If you ever wondered why many people have such a poor opinion of the justice system, it's because of cases like Carl Wayne Buntion. The Fifth Circuit recently reversed a order from the Federal District Court which had granted relief from his death sentence. The District judge concluded the trial court judge was biased, and therefore Buntion did not receive a fair trial. The Judge was William Harmon from Houston, who among other things, put up a post card of "hanging judge" Roy Bean during the trial. He also made the statement that he was "doing God's work" to see that Buntion was executed. If that wasn't enough, he changed several rulings after calling the District Attorney's office during trial, and getting advice them. He also tried to remove one of the lawyers, and then realized he couldn't do that. When the lawyers tried to have him removed, he threatened to accuse them of possessing drugs if they didn't stop challenging his behavior. The truly amazing thing is that most of the allegations were not disputed.
It's not too difficult why the federal district judge concluded the judge was biased. He obviously saw what happened, and knew something needed to be done.
Obtaining relief in a federal habeas proceeding is an extremely difficult thing to do. Much of the difficulty is the result of the standard of review. The courts are reviewing State court decisions, and will not second guess them unless they really stepped out of line. That means a federal court can believe a state court made the wrong decision, and still not grant relief. In a convoluted legal decision, the Fifth Circuit held the District Court should not have granted relief. That means Buntion is likely to be executed, after a trial presided over by a judge who at the very least did not comport himself to the standards we expect from judges.
It is difficult to imagine how anyone could think Buntion received a fair trial. The court noted the judge's action should not be commended (duh!), but apparently they were not so far out of line to establish bias. You have to wonder what else would it take. I'm sure most people expect more from their judges. Thankfully, this is a rare situation. However, that does not excuse a refusal to act. I'm sure Mr. Buntion and his family are not comforted by the assurance that this is a rare occurrence
If we expect the public to have any confidence in our system of justice we have to be willing to take action when the system breaks down. Unfortunately, that didn't happen here.
