Is there any doubt clemency is political decision ?
Several weeks ago Randall Thompson's future was probably looking pretty good. He was scheduled to be executed, but the parole board voted to recommend a commutation to life. In Texas that's a rare thing - I'm sure his lawyers had to look several times to make sure they were reading it right. If you compare it to the lottery, he was told all his numbers matched. All he had to do was collect his money - in this case get the approval of the Governor.
The governor of course is Rick Perry - who just happens to be engaged in a heated primary election. Never thought to be soft on the death penalty, Gov. Perry had commuted sentences before based on the parole board recommendation. Too bad he didn't do it in this case - Mr. Thompson was executed after Gov. Perry refused to follow the recommendation.
I'm sure Gov. Perry has his reasons - just like he continues to insist Todd Willingham is guilty. I think the truth is that he didn't want a commutation to be an campaign ssue. His base of support is to put it mildly "off the chart" on criminal justice issues. They believe in more crimes, and tougher punishments. Heaven forbid you suggest someone shouldn't be executed - even if there are doubts about their guilt.
The bottom line is that if Mr. Thompson's execution had been scheduled a few months earlier he would probably be spending the rest of his life in prison - just like his co-defendant.
This was upsetting enough; then I had to read Mark Bennett's comments, which included a post by Mr. Thompson's habeas attorney. It appears that Mr. Thompson was the victim of an all too often situation - bad lawyering. Any doubt is dispelled by looking at what happened to his co-defendant, who was represented by a good lawyer. In short, the justice system failed him.
I've written before about my belief that we are all going to be accountable for our actions some day. Most of us have a lot of things we aren't proud of - and aren't going to get off the off the hook for. Imagine having to explain why you thought it was better to let someone be executed so you wouldn't damage your re-election chances.
There has to be a better way to handle death penalty cases. Whatever it is, it's not leaving decisions in the hands of those who worried more about their own future - i.e. politicians. They are always going to be decisions with political ramifications. Any doubt - look at the the heat coming down on Mike Huckabee for reducing the sentence of Randall Clemmons (who recently gunned down four police officers). When a decision like that goes bad, it's easy pickings for your opponents.
Politics should not enter into decisions on clemency and communation. In fact, the political ramifiactions of a decision have nothing to do with the meritts. Unfortunately, as long as politicians are the ones making those decisions, it will remain.
