The next step - reviewing non DNA cases
A recent Dallas Morning News editorial applauded District Attorney Craig Watkins for agreeing to scrutinize non-DNA case. I applaud him too; unfortunately, he is probably going to be in the minority. In fact, I would be surprised if any other elected District Attorney decides to follow his lead. In non-DNA cases, the knee jerk reaction is to fight them tooth and nail. In the absence of conclusive proof (like DNA) few prosecutors are going to agree that a person is innocent. I have seen this most often in recantation cases. Granted, most recantations are false, but many prosecutors refuse to acknowledge the possibility that at least some of them are true. If you plead guilty, your odds are even worse. Until prosecutors are willing to honestly accept the fact that there are a substantial number of innocent people of prison, this problem is not going to be resolved.
A recent blogger reported a prediction that the next wave of innocence cases will be arson convictions. I certainly hope that's true, because I have one. Almost everyone agrees that what was known about arson investigation back in 1980's was wrong; much of it was nothing more than "old wives tales". The result was that many fires were declared to be intentionally set, when they were probably accidents. These cases are unique, because you are not claiming someone else committed the crime; in fact, no crime was committed. Unfortunately, that has been the biggest hurdle to overcome, because many people refuse to believe that no one is responsible for the deaths that result from these fires.
DNA cases are easy, especially when you can prove who actually committed the offense. These cases are far more difficult, although the defendants are no less innocent. Judges and prosecutors are going to have to step up and do the right thing. I hope I'm wrong, but I think Mr. Watkins is going to be part of a very small minority. I hope voters don't hold that against him, and you know it will be an issue. Even if they do, I have no doubt he will be rewarded.
